JUMP TO SOLUTION Solved

Original topic:

S23 ultra camera over exposed

(Topic created: 02-20-2023 08:08 PM)
7338 Views
Ash45
Asteroid
Options
Galaxy S23

image
Notice top three window panes on the right side. There are bricks on the wall but in the picture it's totally blown up.

Is anyone facing camera oversaturation issue with s23 ultra ? 
152 Replies
Options
Galaxy S23
Not sure if we're allowed to link to other forums, but I started a thread about it here: https://forums.androidcentral.com/index.php?threads/1056881/
0 Likes
theMinister
Constellation
Options
Galaxy S23
Thank you everybody! I hope we can get to the bottom of this
0 Likes
spagoot
Halo
Options
Galaxy S23
So I'm really confused here because this is the entire point of me saving money for the past 3 years and if I can't figure this out, I think I'm going to give up and just return this to get something cheap to hold me over for a couple more years. 

The 200mp and RAW images are substantially lower quality and resolution than the compressed JPEGs.

Additionally, the RAW images get really blown out post processing. 

Why is this?

How do I stop this post processing effect?

Does anyone have a camera app they can suggest to replace the stock one?

I'm using both the stock and the expert raw apps to test, taking photos in a bunch of different settings and conditions. 

The stock app makes much better pictures than the expert raw one, both in pro and auto modes. 

All photos taken in 1x zoom. 

The phone as a whole is kind of a usability nightmare, but I'd make so many amends for a good camera. For this to struggle so hard is actually pretty saddening.
spagoot
Halo
Options
Galaxy S23
Note this is for the 512gb S23U
TheGalaxy
Sun
Options
Galaxy S23
Because they are not processed, hence the name, raw
0 Likes
otsog
Asteroid
Options
Galaxy S23
Then why does a purposely underexposed image snap to a "normally exposed" image a few seconds later?
JesseB0137
Asteroid
Options
Galaxy S23
I noticed this too, even comparing to the s22+, the s23u has worse low light photos AND auto focus in dark environments don't work on the s23u for me
betancd
Sun
Options
Galaxy S23
RAW files contain loads of information you usually can't see in the preview alone, to unlock the power of RAW you will need an editing app like Light room to edit those files and bring out details. JPEGs files are edited by the phone immediately after taking the photo but the original information is lost and all you are left with is the edited/compressed file. A RAW file is like a negative from film, you have to edit those as well when you develop them to get the look you want.
0 Likes
spagoot
Halo
Options
Galaxy S23
This problem persists when viewing images on a 32" 4k screen

Furthermore, if you jump to image preview before postprocessing (??) is complete on the *raw* images, the images look worse after whatever's going on is complete. The previews look so much more crisp at every zoom level.
spagoot
Halo
Options
Galaxy S23
I'm aware of what raw and jpeg are - I've been doing photography for maybe a decade now, mostly digital.

That's why this baffles me - this isn't what the experience is supposed to be.

The RAW typically looks darker compared to a fully automatic photograph, which makes sense

But my concern isn't vividness - it's that the raw images are blurrier/more pixelated and are harder to bring to color/brightness parity with the compressed/postprocessed jpeg.

It's hard to make a raw image look as pretty if you don't know what you're doing, but the raw image inherently should be more detail rich to allow that. That's what's missing/wrong here.